Switching from Royal Caribbean to Virgin Voyages means giving up waterslides, the buffet, the main dining room, the drink package and kids on board. You gain an adults only ship where specialty dining, basic Wi-Fi and fitness classes are included, and a crew and Happenings Cast that make it easy to talk to people.
I have sailed Royal Caribbean 12 times, six as a kid and six as an adult, and Virgin Voyages 38 times. My last Royal Caribbean sailing was Icon of the Seas over spring break 2025.
I have a dozen more Virgin Voyages sailings booked and none on Royal Caribbean, so you know where I landed. But friends and family I have brought over still tell me what they miss, and it is a real list.
So here is everything you lose, everything you gain, and an honest answer on who should stay put.
The Thrills: Waterslides, Rock Walls and Ice Rinks

Depending on the ship, Royal Caribbean gives you waterslides, a rock climbing wall, a surf simulator, an ice rink, go-karts and mini golf. If the ship itself is the destination, that is hard to beat.
Virgin Voyages has pools, hot tubs, a running track, an athletic court and a gym. The ships hold 2,770 sailors, so there is simply no room for a waterpark.
One small win: the arcade on Virgin Voyages is free. On Royal Caribbean, it ends up on your cruise card.
The Buffet: Grab a Plate vs Order at The Galley

The Windjammer buffet is a system, and it is a satisfying one. You walk in, build a plate in 90 seconds, pick your own portions and eat right away.
Virgin Voyages has no buffet. The Galley is a food hall where you order at a counter, or sit down, raise a flag and let the crew take your order.
There are grab and go fridges in The Galley and on deck 7 by The Dock, but the selection is nothing like the Windjammer. On Virgin Voyages, most things are made to order, so you trade speed for quality.
The Main Dining Room, Set Times and the Same Waiter
My parents have cruised hundreds of times, and the main dining room is what they would miss most. Same time every night, the same waiter all week, and often the same tablemates.
They have made friends for life at those tables and now plan cruises with them. There is no version of that on Virgin Voyages.
What you get instead: every restaurant is included, with no specialty dining package. The tradeoff is that you book each dinner yourself in the app or on the website, and here is my strategy for booking Virgin Voyages dinners.
Comfort Food and the Classics
Royal Caribbean does the classics well: shrimp cocktail, New York cheesecake, steakhouse cuts at Chops. It is familiar, and there is something on the menu for everyone.
Virgin Voyages leans more cutting edge with its menus. The classics are there, like the filet mignon and the seafood tower at The Wake, but you have to look for them.
Most of the menu is included. A few dishes carry an upcharge, such as the seafood tower at about $95 and the tomahawk at about $125, while the filet mignon costs nothing extra.
The Drink Package vs the Bar Tab

On Royal Caribbean you buy the drink package, and then you stop thinking about it. One big bill up front, no math all week.
Virgin Voyages has no drink package. You load a Bar Tab and pay for what you drink, and sailors coming over from Royal Caribbean often stress about the math.
The closest thing is a RockStar suite: a daily drinks hour at Richard’s Rooftop and an in-cabin bar stocked once. In a Mega RockStar suite, the in-cabin bar is unlimited and drinks around the ship are included up to about $25 a drink. More on that in my RockStar perks breakdown.
What I Actually Spent on Drinks on Each Line

Icon of the Seas, 7 nights over spring break 2025, balcony cabin: about $4,000 for two. The drink package was $1,484 for two, and it only covers drinks up to $14.
I drink champagne, so I paid about $600 more on top of the package. That is roughly $2,000 in drinks, half the price of the cruise.
My comparison on Virgin Voyages: 7 nights in Europe over the 4th of July, balcony cabin, about $3,200. On the days I drank champagne it ran about $50, and on long port days I barely drank at all.
That is the real difference. With a package, you feel like you have to drink to make it worth it. With a Bar Tab, you only pay for the days you want a drink.
For every bar price on board, see my guide to drink costs on Virgin Voyages.
Don’t forget to pack THIS!
Virgin Voyages has reimagined sailing and what you need to pack on for this trip is DIFFERENT than a normal cruise line. There are many items I wish I knew to bring (that I didn’t have with me on my first sailing).
Get a free printable pack list and save yourself the headache!

OR if you’re just looking for some inspo! See the curated list of Amazon items I’ve put together (and use!) for Virgin Voyages.
Big Groups and Kids
Royal Caribbean has been at this since the 1970s, and it has a real system for big groups. If grandma, grandpa, 10 aunts and uncles and 20 friends are coming, it handles that well.
Virgin Voyages launched in 2021 and its groups program is still growing. It has a groups coordinator who does a great job, but the ships and venues are smaller, so a group of 50 or more is harder to seat together.
Virgin Voyages is also adults only, 18 and over, on every sailing. If anyone in your group is under 18, the answer is Royal Caribbean.
Perfect Day at CocoCay vs The Beach Club at Bimini

Perfect Day at CocoCay is a whole island owned by Royal Caribbean, with pools, beaches, thrills and a long list of things to do. It can also feel crowded when several Royal Caribbean ships are in port at once.
Virgin Voyages does not own an island, and it does not own Bimini. The Beach Club at Bimini is exclusive to Virgin Voyages sailors when the ship is in port, through a partnership.
You will always find a seat at The Beach Club. The best spots by the pool still go early, same as anywhere. Here is my full guide to The Beach Club at Bimini.
The Casino and the Big Production Shows

Icon of the Seas holds more than 7,000 people, and a bigger ship means a bigger casino floor. Virgin Voyages is adding casino space as ships go through dry dock, but it will not match that.
The same goes for production shows. There is no aqua theater, no ice show and no 5,000 seat theater on Virgin Voyages.
The shows on Virgin Voyages are a different style. They are cheeky and often cheesy with adult humor, not raunchy, but not the squeaky clean family humor Royal Caribbean sailors are used to.
If a stray swear word would ruin your night, know that going in. My entertainment tips show what the shows are actually like.
Fleet Size, Itineraries, Cabins and Status

Royal Caribbean has a huge fleet: old ships at low prices, big ships, medium ships, and itineraries all over the world. Virgin Voyages has four Lady ships with almost the same layout.
That has an upside. Once you have sailed one Virgin Voyages ship, you know your way around all of them. Here is a breakdown of what is actually different between the ships.
You also lose cabin variety and loyalty status. A big Royal Caribbean ship has more cabin categories than you can count, and Virgin Voyages has no status match right now.
If you hold top status on Royal Caribbean and it matters to you, stay. I would never fly another airline when I had top status with one.
Not sure if we can get you the best deal? Learn more about us in Virgin Voyages Facebook group by clicking here!
What You Gain: The Social Temperature

Instead of one cruise director, Virgin Voyages has a Happenings Cast of about 12. They run the parties and events, and they make it easy to talk to other sailors if you want to.
On Icon of the Seas, I spoke to two people outside my own family all week, and only because we played pickleball against them. On Virgin Voyages, I talk to people every day.
The crew is part of it too. They can show their tattoos, wear their hair how they like and chat, so it feels relaxed rather than formal.
Adults only changes the feel as well. My favorite thing to watch on Virgin Voyages is parents who finally let their shoulders down, because nobody needs checking on.
And there is no dress code. Formal night is gone, and you do not even have to wear red on Scarlet Night.
What You Gain: What Is Actually Included
On Icon of the Seas, three nights of specialty dining cost us about $600 extra. On Virgin Voyages, every restaurant is included.
Basic Wi-Fi, group fitness classes, still and sparkling water, sodas and juices are included too. I take two fitness classes a day on Virgin Voyages, and on Royal Caribbean I paid around $20 a class.
One honest note: gratuities are no longer baked into the fare. Since October 2025, they are a separate daily charge.
They are $20 per sailor, per day if you prepay, or $22 onboard. Details in my Virgin Voyages gratuities guide and the full what is included list.
Two fun extras you will not find on Royal Caribbean: a tattoo parlor at sea, and Shake for Champagne, where you shake the Virgin Voyages app and a bottle of champagne is brought to you wherever you are on the ship.
Who Should Stay With Royal Caribbean
- You are traveling with kids or grandkids under 18.
- You are organizing a group of 25, 50 or 100 people.
- The ship is the destination and you want the waterslides, rock wall and zip line.
- You want the lowest possible price, and an older ship is fine.
- You love the main dining room, your waiter team and formal night with the ship photographer.
- You hold top status and care about the perks.
If none of those are you, try Virgin Voyages. It does not have to be a big commitment: a 4 night sailing from Miami to Key West and Bimini is easy, quick and affordable to fly into.
Royal Caribbean vs Virgin Voyages FAQ
Is Virgin Voyages better than Royal Caribbean? For adults who want included dining, a social atmosphere and no kids, yes. For families, big groups and anyone who wants waterslides and a buffet, Royal Caribbean is the better fit.
Does Virgin Voyages have a drink package? No. You pay as you go with a Bar Tab. A Mega RockStar suite is the closest thing, with drinks included up to about $25 each.
Does Virgin Voyages have a buffet? No. The Galley is a food hall where you order from different counters, and the food is included.
Does Virgin Voyages allow kids? No. Every sailing is adults only, 18 and over.
Are gratuities included on Virgin Voyages? Not anymore. Since October 2025 they are $20 per sailor, per day prepaid, or $22 onboard.
Who is Virgin Voyages for? Mostly not the young party crowd people expect. On my fall foliage sailing the average age was 62, and on a European sailing last year it was 55.
Royal Caribbean vs Virgin Voyages: The Short Version
Royal Caribbean wins on thrills, the buffet, the main dining room, big groups, kids and choice of ships. Virgin Voyages wins on included dining, a social adults only atmosphere, a relaxed crew and no dress code.
You do not have to switch for good. Try a short Virgin Voyages sailing, see how it feels, and decide from there.
My co-agent JC and I are Top 10 Virgin Voyages First Mates out of 33,000+ agents, with 60+ sailings between us. We can book Royal Caribbean too, so ask us either way.


